A Head of Engineering sits between technical excellence and business delivery. They must be credible with engineers, trusted by the Managing Director and able to turn technical decisions into products, programmes and margin. Candidates who combine all three are scarce, and the cost of a poor appointment shows up in late projects, quality problems and the loss of good engineers.
This guide sets out how to recruit a Head of Engineering, based on how we run engineering leadership searches at EMA Partners Executive Headhunters.
Why engineering leadership hires go wrong
Many engineering leaders are promoted or hired for technical strength, then struggle with the leadership side of the role. McKinsey's review of the research found that 68% of failed leadership transitions come down to politics, culture and people, and that between 27% and 46% of transitions are judged failures or disappointments two years in.
The knock-on effect is significant. When leaders struggle, McKinsey found their direct reports perform 15% worse and are 20% more likely to disengage or leave. In engineering, where skilled people are hard to replace, that can stall a programme for a year or more.
Step 1: Define the brief
Be clear about the technical domain and the leadership challenge:
- Technical scope. Mechanical, electrical, electronic, software, systems or a mix.
- Lifecycle. New product development, sustaining engineering, manufacturing engineering or field support.
- Regulation and standards. Sector certifications, safety cases and quality systems the role must own.
- Leadership. Size of team, number of sites and whether the team needs building, stabilising or changing.
- Commercial. Budget responsibility, supplier management and input to bids or pricing.
Step 2: Agree success measures
Set measures for the first 12 and 24 months: programme delivery, quality, cost, team capability and retention. Agree how engineering will work with operations, sales and the Managing Director, and which decisions the Head of Engineering owns.
Step 3: Search a wide but relevant market
The best engineering leaders are rarely looking and are often well protected by their employers. A retained search maps leaders in your sector and in adjacent sectors with comparable engineering challenges. Automotive, aerospace, defence, rail and marine businesses, for example, share many disciplines and standards. Candidates are approached directly and in confidence.
Step 4: Assess technical judgement and leadership
A structured process for a Head of Engineering might include:
- Search interview covering programmes delivered, teams led and technical depth.
- Technical interview with a senior engineer, CTO or trusted adviser.
- Leadership interview with the Managing Director.
- Case exercise on a real technical or programme challenge from your business.
- Team meetings with the engineers they will lead.
Our validated profiling tools give an objective view of leadership style, decision-making and how the candidate will work with your team.
Questions worth asking a Head of Engineering candidate
- Tell us about a programme that was running late. What did you do?
- How do you balance technical ambition with cost and delivery?
- Describe a time you had to tell the board something they did not want to hear.
- How have you developed and kept strong engineers?
Step 5: Onboard for retention
New engineering leaders need time to understand products, systems and people before they change them. McKinsey found that 92% of external hires take well over 90 days to reach full productivity, and that tailored coaching and integration plans can double the likelihood of a successful transition.
Every executive appointment we make includes Landing With Impact: six months of one-to-one coaching for your new Head of Engineering, covering early priorities, stakeholder relationships and leading the team through change. Leading With Impact extends this to months seven to twelve and extends our replacement guarantee from nine to twelve months. Both are part of our Leadership Advisory service.
How long does it take?
Most Head of Engineering searches take between 8 and 14 weeks from briefing to an accepted offer. Notice periods are often three months or more. If a programme cannot wait, an interim engineering leader can step in.
Talk to us
EMA Partners Executive Headhunters is the UK office of EMA Partners, an AESC member firm established in 1988, with more than 40 offices in 30 countries. Every appointment carries a nine-month free replacement guarantee. Book a confidential consultation or call 020 7160 6996.
Read more about our engineering executive search, or see how we appointed a Head of Engineering for an automotive manufacturer.
Sources
- Scott Keller and Mary Meaney, Successfully transitioning to new leadership roles, McKinsey & Company, May 2018.




